Get a Free Ebook

Five Inspirational Truths for Authors

Thursday, April 05, 2007

Ane's Take

I made these notes as I read. I didn't care for the prologue, too fragmented. Does it really need to be there? I think (and this is only my opinion – worth about two cents) if you cut the Slap, slap line, it would read a whole lot better.

You use some wonderful descriptions in here and some good similes. You tend to overdo some, like the sweating. Remember less is more. That said, your similes are good ones; just don't use so many they lose their punch.

I'd like to see this start a bit later that it does. I got really interested when she was climbing the stairs and thought about Tim and the tree being trimmed. I loved how her legs shook from the weight of her pregnancy. Great description. You do a bit too much telling instead of showing. Like when she realized she was sobbing. Not realistic. Sobbing doesn't sneak up on a person. A stray tear might, but not sobbing.

I was a bit confused about Tom. In one part I thought he was dead, then at the end, it appears he's in Iraq.

All-in-all, I think this has the bones of a good story, but it needs a lot of work. I really want to encourage you to keep refining this. It needs tightening and focus. I wasn't sure where it was going or what your heroine's goal is—something to make the reader invest in her. What does she want? You might get a copy of GMC, Goal, Motivation and conflict by Debra Dixon.

Related Posts:

  • Awesome Book and It's Free Today... (Gina Holmes here.) One of the best writers alive or dead I've read is none other than one of my best friend Jessica Dotta. She's destined for greatness. Truly. Today her debut (first book in a trilogy) is FREE. It's a got… Read More
  • The Stories God Loves Most by Allen Arnold Imagine you are invited to a dinner party where the host is known for telling great stories. You can learn a lot about a host by the stories he chooses to tell around the table. Does he enjoy stories that … Read More
  • A PERSON OF ACTIONby Cynthia Ruchti When a novelist tangles with an opening line that flops in death throes on the page, or peeks into the Mason jar marked "Marketing Funds" and sees that the contents barely cover the bottom of the jar, or hu… Read More
  • Heart of a Writer Heart of a Writer   by Reba Hoffman (used with permission from My Book Therapy) Let’s face it. You’re cut from a different cloth. You see the world through a strange set of eyes. You look for ways to murder people … Read More
  • Choke 'em up. by Nicole Petrino-Salter There is room for tears in any novel. The difficult part is finding where they belong in the story. I know: it seems obvious. Emotional scenes where death is present, imminent, or recalled. A bre… Read More